PP-DB'S FALSE STARTS

by Anthony Georgieff

Ruling 'fixture' quickly becomes laughing stock

bulgarian traffic cop.jpg

Notwithstanding the amendments to the Constitution proposed by Nikolay Denkov's "fixture" (the word he uses to describe the government), several bits of legislation put forward by the rulers and quickly voted into law have raised eyebrows and prompted a significant amount of laughter. Critics have viewed them not as just poorly thoughtover and hastily fixed (pun unintended) pieces of legal literature but as evidence that in spite of the huge claims of competence by the PP-DB "clever and beautiful" intellectuals the goods actually delivered have been at least substandard.

An atrocious case of a sadistically mutilated young woman in Stara Zagora spawned a public outcry. Initially, the local courts just let the perpetrator go free, citing the current laws that did not envisage "domestic violence" outside families. Sensing the onslaught of popular discontent – the case will probably go down in history as one of the most heinous in latterday Bulgaria – the PP-DB quickly forged an amendment to expand the concept of "domestic violence." Now, to "qualify" for domestic violence, a case should entail... an "intimate relationship."

You've read that right. The Bulgarian Parliament has introduced a legal concept for intimate relationships. This is the exact wording: "An intimate relationship is the aggregation of voluntary, lasting, personal, intimate and sexual relations between two natural person of male and female sex, regardless of whether they share a household, and whose commencement, contents and termination have not been regulated by another law. 'Lasting' is determined as continuing for at least 60 days."

The initial anger of the public caused by the Stara Zagora case quickly turned into amusement. Dozens of jokes about "intimate relationships" were put into circulation. Bogus "forms" designed to prove the commencement of an "intimate relationship" between consenting adults appeared on the Internet.

On a more serious note, legal experts were quick to point out that the new PP-DB law was plainly unconstitutional. Speaking specifically of persons of a male and female sex, it clearly excluded all LGBT, a unapologetic act of discrimination which is at loggerheads with the Universal Human Rights Charter and is prohibited by the Bulgarian Constitution.

Another, equally silly law passed by the PP-DB concerns DUI driving. DUI driving, usually involving alcohol but increasingly drugs, is a serious problem on Bulgarian roads. In recent years it has caused many incidents, including some with lethal outcome.

In their quest to produce an appearance that they are doing something good for the public except wanting to get the Red Army Monument in central Sofia knocked down, the PP-DB decided to tackle the DUI issue speedily and resolutely. They amended the Traffic Law to enable the police to seize vehicles driven by DUI drivers.

Most of the public received the amendment well. Drunken drivers should be punished severely if they are a threat to public safety, the people of Sofia, Plovdiv, Burgas and the smaller towns surmised. But the uneasy questions were quick to follow.

What if a DUI driver drives a car that is not his or her property? What if it is a company car? What if it is a company long-haul truck? What if the vehicle is jointly owned by a husband and wife (regardless of the "intimate relationship" status discussed above)?

The initial public endorsement quickly turned into bemused discontent. To start off with, in a place like Bulgaria any new or additional regulation, especially if the Traffic Police are involved, is seen as yet another gateway to corruption.

Plainly put, the inconsistency of the new law seems to outshine its declared purposes, to inflict just punishment on DUI drivers and make the roads safer.

Any confiscation of a vehicle should be done following a court ruling. One of the prerequisites for a proper court trial is a valid blood test done in a laboratory, in addition to the breathalyser on the road the traffic police handle. A blood and narcotics test in Bulgaria is done in... three laboratories, two in Sofia and one in Varna. Results usually take months to come out.

During those months a driver will be left without a driving license and a car. And if the blood test, which is without a question a lot more reliable than the breathalyser, is negative he or she will have the option to sue the police for unlawful seizure of property. A court case against the police will likely take years...

What lawyers advise at the moment is never to sign a protocol for voluntary forfeiture of your vehicle if you are suspected of DUI. Such a protocol will have the legal power to thwart your later actions against the cops.

Perhaps the most ridiculous proposal by the PP-DB – so far just a proposal – introduces the concept of individual claims to the Constitutional Court. If adopted, the amendment will enable any Bulgarian, who feels his or her Constitutional rights have been infringed upon, to file a complaint with the Constitutional Court. Sounds good, right?!

Trouble is, the Constitutional Court is not a part of the Bulgarian justice administration system at all. The Constitutional Court has no power to repeal rulings by other courts, nor to dictate to them what to do. Its decisions cannot be enforced by for example a bailiff or the police. The purpose of the Bulgarian Constitutional Court is to interpret whether any act of the state or its agencies, including the legal amendments and proposed bills, do not go against the basic law. Whether the agency found to be at fault complies with the Constitutional Court ruling is entirely optional. Bad news for the hundreds of Bulgarians who started sharpening their pencils to file complaints about their presumably infringed Constitutional rights.

The political question about the "Intimate Relationship" act, the DUI amendments and the individual Constitutional Court complaints has two sides. Are the PP-DB legal "experts," who claim Western education in top law schools, so silly? Or is the PP-DB in a rush just to manifest some kind of activity and reassure its supporters that it is doing something meaningful ahead of the local elections scheduled for October?

  • COMMENTING RULES

    Commenting on www.vagabond.bg

    Vagabond Media Ltd requires you to submit a valid email to comment on www.vagabond.bg to secure that you are not a bot or a spammer. Learn more on how the company manages your personal information on our Privacy Policy. By filling the comment form you declare that you will not use www.vagabond.bg for the purpose of violating the laws of the Republic of Bulgaria. When commenting on www.vagabond.bg please observe some simple rules. You must avoid sexually explicit language and racist, vulgar, religiously intolerant or obscene comments aiming to insult Vagabond Media Ltd, other companies, countries, nationalities, confessions or authors of postings and/or other comments. Do not post spam. Write in English. Unsolicited commercial messages, obscene postings and personal attacks will be removed without notice. The comments will be moderated and may take some time to appear on www.vagabond.bg.

Add new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

Restricted HTML

  • Allowed HTML tags: <a href hreflang> <em> <strong> <cite> <blockquote cite> <code> <ul type> <ol start type> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <h2 id> <h3 id> <h4 id> <h5 id> <h6 id>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.

Discover More

WITH BOTH EUROS IN THE PAST
In spite of the protestations of the ruling "fixture" between PP-DB (Changes Continued of Kiril Petkov and Asen Vasilev and Democratic Bulgaria of Gen Atanas Atanasov and Hristo Ivanov) and Boyko Borisov's GERB about the "top national pri

WHO IS AFRAID OF VASIL 'SKULL' BOZHKOV?
While Bulgarians left, right and centre are quibbling over the fate of a pile of stones crowned by some sculpted Red Army soldiers in central Sofia, the state prosecution service quietly terminated a case started by Vasil Bozhkov, one of this country's weal

RUMOURS OF GERB'S DEMISE TURN OUT TO BE PREMATURE
Polling agencies got it wrong again

CHURCH OF DISCONTENT
Colourful and gilt-domed, looking like a toy, the St Nicholas the Miracle-Worker church in central Sofia is known to Bulgarians simply as the Russian Church.

UPS & DOWNS OF BULGARIAN ANTISEMITISM
А crudely-cut cartoon circulating on social media shows Former Foreign Minister Solomon Pasi, who is Jewish, being held by two Nazi-clad soldiers. The text (in Bulgarian) reads: "If you don't want Russian gas, we will give you some of ours."

IT'S THE HISTORY, STUPID!
In 2013, when the Inland Revenue agency started a probe into alleged wrongdoing by then President Rosen Plevneliev, he famously excused himself: I am not a Martian. Plevneliev had been a minister for Boyko Borisov.

BYE-BYE, IVAN GESHEV
Three years after the event, the massive street protests that blocked the traffic in Central Sofia in the course of months, in 2020, seem to have achieved their original aims.
END OF 'MAFIA STATE'?
If anyone believed that the CC-DB, or Changes Continued-Democratic Bulgaria alliance, who lost the April election and are now the second largest party in the Bulgarian National Assembly, were serious in their declared and oft-repeated pledges they wanted to

WILL THE DISGUSTED EMBRACE THE DISGUSTING?
Despite the massive and apparently rather expensive advertising campaign, which involved TV, print, outdoor and plenty of Facebook, the Changes Continued-Democratic Bulgaria (CC-DB) alliance lost the 2 April election.
LONG LIVE RED ARMY MONUMENT!
Whenever developed democracies hold a general election, at stake – usually – are pressing issues of the day. Oil, terrorism, immigration. Nuclear weapons. Abortion rights. Inflation. Climate change. The cost of living...

WHO IS WHO AND WHO WANTS WHAT IN THE UPCOMING BULGARIAN GENERAL ELECTION?
It was called by President Rumen Radev, who is now the de facto ruler of this country, acting through the caretaker governments he appoints, because the previous election, in October 2022, failed to produce any kind of political alignment that could form a
BYE-BYE, SCHENGEN
The Netherlands and Austria have decided not to endorse Bulgaria's acceptance in Schengen, the European system for police and legal cooperation that allows for passport-less travel between member states.