ISSUE OF NORTH MACEDONIA

ISSUE OF NORTH MACEDONIA

Fri, 10/30/2020 - 12:39

Bulgarian nationalists pose adamant demands on former Yugoslav republic

01052014-5980.jpg
Britain's wartime leader Winston Churchill, sporting his telltale V-sign, sits atop North Macedonia's new foreign ministry

In Bulgaria, Winston Churchill (who held southeastern Europe in contempt) is sometimes quoted as saying the Balkans have more history than they are able to stomach. The 20th century offers many examples of internecine conflicts and wars anyone, not just the Balkans, would have found too difficult to come to terms with. Beginning with the two Balkans wars, which preceded the First World War (in which the various Balkan states found themselves along opposed battlefronts), the exchange of populations in the 1910s and 1920s (between Turkey, Greece and Bulgaria), the Second World War (in which Balkan nation confronted another Balkan nation), the ensuing civil wars (in Greece) and the imposition of Communism (in Yugoslavia, Bulgaria and Romania), the mistreatment of various ethnic minorities leading to ethnic cleansing in various forms... all the way to the wars in former Yugoslavia in the 1990s have left large populations displaced and/or in severe political, economic, cultural or identity crises. With the accession of some Balkan states to the EU one might have thought centuries-old disagreements and animosities would have been laid to erst. The most recent example of the spat between Bulgaria, an EU member state, and North Macedonia, an EU member hopeful, suggests otherwise.

What is at stake?

Macedonia, since 2019 known officially as the Republic of North Macedonia, is a tiny, landlocked state bordering on Albania, Kosovo, Serbia, Bulgaria and Greece. Since at least the Middle Ages it has been contested by all of those – as well as, in the 19th and 20th centuries – the Great Powers who, with varying intensity and using various means, have vied for influence over it. Characteristically for the Balkans, the claims of Macedonia's neighbours not only diverge but sometimes have nothing to do with each other. Albania and Kosovo claim the ethnic Albanians in Macedonia (roughly a quarter of the population) should have more rights. Until a year ago Greece was vehemently opposed to the name of the former Yugoslav republic because it coincided with the name of a large identically named province in northern Greece. The Macedonians claim they are the proud descendants of Alexander the Great (whom the Greeks consider to be a major figure in Greek history). The Macedonians also say they speak Macedonian and have a Macedonian identity – proposals that the Bulgarians find impossible to accept because, as one Bulgarian president put it, the history of Macedonia is the "most romantic part of Bulgarian history." The official Bulgarian line is that the modern Macedonian language is but a bastardised version of a western Bulgarian dialect and the Macedonians are in fact Bulgarians who were forcibly "Serbianised" in Communist Yugoslavia after the Second World War. Bulgaria recognises no Macedonian minority in Bulgaria proper, and a shady organisation of "ethnic Macedonians" calling itself OMO-Ilinden remains banned. In Bulgaria, however, there is a political party, called Internal Macedonian Revolutionary Organisation. It is considered by many to be of extreme nationalist inclinations as it is in one block with Valeri Simeonov's National Front for the Salvation of Bulgaria and Volen Siderov's Ataka. It is currently allied with the ruling GERB. Its leader, Krasimir Karakachanov, is Boyko Borisov's defence minister.

Skopje

A rally in central Skopje with the 24-metre-high equestrian statue of Alexander the Great in the background

In 1991, when Macedonia became the only former Yugoslav republic to break away from Belgrade without a war, Bulgaria was the first country to recognise its independence. It said it did so in a bid to foster stability in the region. It has remained intransigent in its refusal to recognise the Macedonian language, leading to a somewhat comical situation where a Macedonian dignitary being interviewed on Bulgarian TV gets no voiceover translation – bemusing for many Bulgarians in western Bulgaria but quite incomprehensible to those in the eastern parts of the country where the local dialect differs significantly from modern Macedonian.

To understand both Greece's opposition to the name and Bulgaria's reluctance to accept the language one might want to conjecture similar situations in the West. Imagine, say, the highly unlikely event of Normandie breaking away from France, declaring independence and starting calling itself the Republic of Kent. How would the people of Kent, still part of the UK, react? Possibly, the main concern of the overwhelming majority would be the continued opportunities to sail across the Channel to buy cheaper wine. But what if the citizens of the new republic lay claims to Canterbury as their historical capital? Or on William the Conquerer as their foremost historical stalwart?

From a purely linguistic point, modern Macedonian is indeed based on western Bulgarian dialects. In the 1950s, however, Skopje employed a team of linguists to devise a codified Macedonian language sufficiently distinct from Bulgarian. They did – and over the next decades that language developed in entirely different directions from modern Bulgarian. To claim that modern Macedonian is but Bulgarian is like to insist modern Norwegian is in fact Danish with some unusual pronunciation.

The situation is further compounded by the realities of everyday life. The perceived notion of many Bulgarians, some of whom third or fourth generation descendants of ethnic Bulgarians who settled in Bulgaria proper as a result of the early 20th century exchanges of populations, is that they are "Macedonians." After a few drinks many Bulgarians will happily start signing Macedonian songs and declare themselves "Macedonian."

In recent years, a significant number of Macedonians from the former Yugoslav republic have taken a more practical approach to the issue of their identify. They have applied, and been granted, Bulgarian citizenship – an easy course of action as the Bulgarian authorities favour anyone who can prove Bulgarian lineage. With Bulgarian EU passports under their belts they now have legitimate access to Western Europe and beyond.

Greece used to block Skopje's attempt to join the EU and other Western structures for many years over the name of Macedonia, but the dispute was settled in 2019 through diplomacy. The language, history and identity issues with Bulgaria remain nowhere near it.

Bulgaria and North Macedonia set up a joint commission three years ago to settle the outstanding historical issues. The commission, consisting of historians, linguists and diplomats on both sides, have so far agreed on some historical issues including King Samuil (the 11th century Bulgarian king whom the Macedonians consider to be their own) and Alphabet Day (marked on 24 May and celebrating the creation of the Cyrillic alphabet in the 9th century). According to Bulgarian Professor Ivan Ilchev, however, there is still "a sea of disagreement," with no likely solution in sight.

One of the major issues of discontent on the negotiating table is the nationality of Gotse Delchev, the 19th century revolutionary whom both Bulgaria and Macedonia hold as a staple in their national mythologies. In western Bulgaria Gotse Delchev is the namesake of a town, while the remains of the actual man are buried across the border in Skopje.

In Bulgaria in the meantime, Krasimir Karakachanov's Internal Macedonian Revolutionary Organisation is adamant it will never recognise either the existence of the Macedonian language or of a Macedonian identity. To better ram the message home with his voters, Karakachanov also adds he will never accept the Istanbul Convention on the Rights of Women and Children, will block gay marriages and will continue to view the term "gender" as a diabolical invention of decadent Western civilisation designed to deprive the Orthodox Bulgarians of what he refers to as "traditional Bulgarian values."

For the time being the issue of North Macedonia is nowhere to a solution, not as far as Bulgaria is concerned. Interestingly, Karakachanov's language indicates he and his VMRO supporters are more concerned about airtime ahead of the 2021 general election that will have to deal with a lot more important present-day issues like the rule of law, corruption and the quality of democracy in Bulgaria rather than the national identity of 19th century revolutionaries. But, like so many times in Bulgarian history, the issue of Macedonia (and these days the issue of gay marriages) is so emotional that common sense barely stands a chance. 

And Now for the Salad...

salad

Interestingly, no one can agree about the salad either. In France, Salade Macédoine is a vegetable salad. In Italy, a Macedonia is a fruit salad. In Greece, Makedoniki salata contains aubergines... It isn't difficult to see why in cuisine the term “macédoine” has come to mean exactly what it means in diplomatic history: a complicated (and inseparable) mixture. 

Issue 169 North Macedonia

Commenting on www.vagabond.bg

Vagabond Media Ltd requires you to submit a valid email to comment on www.vagabond.bg to secure that you are not a bot or a spammer. Learn more on how the company manages your personal information on our Privacy Policy. By filling the comment form you declare that you will not use www.vagabond.bg for the purpose of violating the laws of the Republic of Bulgaria. When commenting on www.vagabond.bg please observe some simple rules. You must avoid sexually explicit language and racist, vulgar, religiously intolerant or obscene comments aiming to insult Vagabond Media Ltd, other companies, countries, nationalities, confessions or authors of postings and/or other comments. Do not post spam. Write in English. Unsolicited commercial messages, obscene postings and personal attacks will be removed without notice. The comments will be moderated and may take some time to appear on www.vagabond.bg.

0 comments

Add new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

Restricted HTML

  • Allowed HTML tags: <a href hreflang> <em> <strong> <cite> <blockquote cite> <code> <ul type> <ol start type> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <h2 id> <h3 id> <h4 id> <h5 id> <h6 id>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.

Discover More

bridge over the danube at ruse
WHAT ABOUT ROMANIA?
Especially in recent years Bulgarian politicians of various inclinations periodically trumpet that this country has fulfilled all the "technical requirements" for membership of Schengen, the police cooperation agreement between most EU states.

WHO ARE VAZRAZHDANE'S VOTERS?
Since the fall of Communism in 1989 and the introduction of multiparty elections the following year Bulgarians have been given a Constitutional right to go to the polls regardless of whether they actually live in Bulgaria or not.
IS CHANGES CONTINUED TO BE CONTINUED?
The most readily available explanation why the Changes Continued government collapsed, propagated by former Prime Minister Kiril Petkov and former Finance Minister Asen Vasilev themselves, is that because it stepped on so many corrupt toes within a short pe
king samuil
IS IT REALLY ABOUT MAKEDONIYA-A-A?
Slavi Trifonov, the showman and crooner credited with propagating chalga culture in Bulgaria, could not have put it more plainly.

communist bulgaria youth
WHAT FEEDS BULGARIAN NOSTALGIA FOR COMMUNISM?
Some years ago the Pew Research Center in Washington DC produced a survey indicating the levels of nostalgia in Bulgaria surpassed by far longing for the past everywhere else in the former East bloc countries. How come?

pro-russia rally bulgaria
IS PUTIN 'WORLD LEADER' OR SADISTIC VILLAIN?
Russia's invasion of Ukraine has polarised public opinion in Bulgaria. In fact, Bulgaria has emerged, since the start of the war in Ukraine, as the only EU state where public support for Putin remains high.

anti ukraine protest bulgaria.jpg
WHY DO SO MANY BULGARIANS SUPPORT PUTIN?
Perhaps surprisingly for a country that was once an enthusiastic applicant to join NATO and the EU Bulgaria is now home to a significant number of people who support... Russia's tyrant Vladimir Putin and his war in Ukraine.

Satan strategic nuclear-head missile, capable of reaching the island of Manhattan in 20-30 minutes after launch
WHAT BULGARIANS GET WRONG ABOUT WAR IN UKRAINE
Though it has been a member of NATO since 2004 and of the EU since 2007 present-day Bulgaria appears not to be very enthusiastic about any involvement in the war in Ukraine.